Each year, as many of you who follow this blog might know, I make my Oscar predictions.
I’m normally pretty good, with a strike rate usually in the mid 90% range.
This year it’s going to be difficult, because I haven’t seen many of the films, and so I’ll be making my predictions on a mix of what I’ve gleaned from the trades since the Venice Film Festival last year, when Tar became a front runner for Cate Blanchett to pick up Best Actress.
Avatar, The Way of the Water and Maverick Top Gun have been huge commercial successes, and many have said they are the two films that have brought audiences back to the cinema. But that’s true to a point.
Having screened my very small film Facing Fear in commercial multiplexes both in Australia late last year, and in the US and Mexico earlier this year, what I witnessed was a paucity of people. The multiplexes I went to were virtually ghost houses. On many occasions my film was the only one that had any significant activity.
I think Todd McCarthy was right when he wrote in The Hollywood Reporter late last year that the cinema going experience, as we’d once known it, was gone and was never coming back. That won’t be the case for the big event movies, like the Avatars and the Top Guns, but for the smaller arthouse or even smaller studio films, everyone now is in the mindset of waiting till it comes out on a streamer. That’s just the thinking now.
Back to the Oscars.
I have two favourite films and one film I dislike with a passion.
My two favourite films are:
All Quiet on the Western Front
Elvis
The film I dislike with a passion:
Everything Everywhere All at Once.
All Quiet on the Western Front is a superbly made film that says powerful things about the human condition, and it was audacious and bold in its storytelling.
Elvis in my opinion is the best biopic of a musician I’ve yet seen. I think it’s Baz Luhrmann’s best film, without a doubt.
I didn’t rush out to see Elvis. Baz’s films, for me, are often times flash before substance, and I’m the only person I know who fell asleep in Moulin Rouge. And please, let’s not discuss Australia. I saw that film three times, not because I wanted to, but due to social obligations. Hugh Jackman soaping his abs while Nicole Kidman looks on adoringly? Silhouettes of an aboriginal man perched on one leg holding a spear, straight off a tea-towel you could have bought at The Rocks in the 1950s?
Give me a break.
But Elvis is in a whole other league.
And Austin Butler is magnificent.
My dear friends Wayne and Libby Pashley, who have done the sound on all my movies since Kiss or Kill in 1996, did the sound for Elvis and they deservedly are up for a Best Sound Oscar. I sincerely hope they win. Their work was impeccable. But the Academy likes noise with their sound so probably the noisiest film of the year, Maverick Top Gun, will get the gong. I hope the voters have more taste and discernment than that.
The film I dislike with a passion?
I just didn’t get Everything, Everywhere…
I admire the film for its outrageous audacity. And Jamie Lee Curtis deserves an Oscar for her performance, which is a total knockout. But the story? Where did that go in all the showmanship of technique? And where was the emotional connection? I stood outside that film as I watched it. It never invited me inside.
Like I say, I’m in awe of its technical and creative bravura. But for me, story is everything and when I became disengaged with the story, about halfway through, the movie lost me.
Okay, so here are my predictions. As I say, I’m taking a bit of a punt this year, because I haven’t seen many of the films – but this is my list:
Best Picture
All Quiet on the Western Front
Best Director
Steven Spielberg / The Fabelmans
Best Actor
Austin Butler / Elvis
Best Actress
Cate Blanchett / Tar
Best Supporting Actor
Ke Huy Quan / Everything Everywhere All at Once
Best Supporting Actress
Jamie Lee Curtis / Everything Everywhere All at Once
Best Original Screenplay
Triangle of Sadness
Best Adapted Screenplay
All Quiet on the Western Front
Best International Film
All Quiet on the Western Front
Best Cinematography
Mandy Walker / Elvis
Best Film Editing
Maverick Top Gun
Best Sound:
Wayne Pashley / Elvis
Best Production Design
Elvis
Visual Effects
Avatar, Way of Water
Original Score
All Quiet on the Western Front
Original Song
Maverick Top Gun
Best Costume Design
Elvis
Best Makeup & Hair
The Whale
Best Documentary
Navalny
Best Animated Feature
Pinocchio
So on Sunday night US time, Monday Australian time, we’ll know the results. We’ll find out whether the film I dislike the most gets the majority of gongs, or the Netflix movie All Quiet on the Western Front, my pick, gets the streamer’s first Best Picture statuette.
Personally, I hope like hell my mates Wayne and Libby Pashley come away with some excess baggage.

You must be logged in to post a comment.